All Articles
All Articles
CULTURE

Interview: Adam Broomberg

CULTURE

Interview: Adam Broomberg

One half of London-based duo Broomberg and Chanarin discusses his interpretation of contemporary war photography

by Nara Shin
on 22 October 2013
Adam-Olly-1.jpg

Photography isn't a practice that's conducive to duos; in fact, from a more general perspective, most contemporary visual artists are solitary figures. Thus, the story of duo Adam Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin is a slightly peculiar yet significant one. Together—through their photography—they provoke political and social questions that many are too content or afraid to ask. And, while recognizing its limitations at the same time, the duo has also tested and pushed the boundaries of photography as a medium by creating contexts for images that continually redefine their nature and purpose. So it makes sense that their 2011 altered book project, "War Primer 2" would be selected for the Musuem of Modern Arts' New Photography 2013 exhibition, making its debut in New York City.

broomberg-chanarin-interview-2.jpg

"War Primer 2" is a modern-day reinterpretation of German poet Bertolt Brecht's 1955 book "War Primer." Brecht wrote four-line poems as captions for World War II clippings, in order to decipher the bourgeoisie-controlled mass media images and portray them from an objective point of view. In this era, when the bourgeoisie no longer have control and anyone—even a civilian or drone—can snap a photo, Broomberg and Chanarin applied the "War Primer" technique to contemporary war images, silkscreening text and superimposing low-resolution screenshots over Brecht's pages. Since 2011, Broomberg and Chanarin have already done two further explorations of Brecht's "War Primer."

We met with Broomberg in Soho—just down the street from the non-profit exhibition space Apexart where the pair have another exhibit—to dissect some of his thoughts on war photography, the invasiveness of cameras, and working in tandem.

broomberg-chanarin-interview-11.jpg
Let's start off with how you and Oliver met.

In South Africa, in a tiny town called Wuppertal on holiday when we were kids, like 17 or something. I was [in South Africa] until I was about 20 and Ollie until he was seven, so he was back for the first time and we just kind of met by accident. We were friends for a good 10 years before we started working together, and that was very organic, the way that started. [In university] Ollie studied philosophy and I studied predominantly history of art and sociology. So we never intended to be photographers or artists or anything. It just happened to us.

When was the moment when the wheels started turning in this new direction?

We actually started working—it's quite a convoluted story, but in the early '90s, Benneton hired Tadao Ando to build what was like a bit of a bunker underneath a vineyard in northern Italy, just outside Venice. And they set up a place for Fabrica, and there's a filmmaker called Godfrey Reggio who did films like "Powaqqatsi" and "Koyaanisqatsi" with Philip Glass, they made him the head, and he sent people around the world, recruiting. I was lucky enough to be invited out—young and broke in London—and the next thing: I landed up in Venice with access to all these facilities and started working on the magazine Colors.

So we started working like that. We were working with other people's images, it was a social and political magazine but using photography a lot. We got increasingly frustrated with not being able to take the pictures, but also these pictures would arrive and you wouldn't know who the person was, and the whole process felt wrong. So we remodeled the format: We'd make a small team, go to the place and embed ourselves in a community and make a thing, and that resulted in a book of ours called "Ghetto," which took three years.

broomberg-chanarin-interview-9.jpg
Was "Ghetto" your first project?

It actually wasn't. Our first project was called "Trust" which is a book as well, and that was also about the photographic process. It started off with various degrees of unconsciousness, it ends with people under general anesthetic. It's about the relationship between the photographer and the subject and how much power, what's the flow of power. Somehow we're always surprised by the fact that people agree to have their photograph taken.

I've never had the courage to say "Stop" when I see people with cameras around New York City photographing buskers or sites, and find myself in the background of the photo or video.

We are always pleasantly surprised by people saying "Stop." It's so invasive. Now, I mean, you're being photographed by cameras everywhere. In fact, one of our most recent projects is in Russia; a few weeks ago we went—they've developed a new technique called "non-collaborative portraiture" in which they set up cameras—say, along traffic lights—in the street and if there's a big demonstration, you'll be obscured by other people. So the camera will capture that amount and the next camera captures that. By the end of that street, or if you would just walk through that door, it constructs a 3-D mask that you can move in space. It's essentially a police portrait—front and side on—without you even knowing or doing anything. It's pretty frightening. We photographed members of the Pussy Riot group and the then-opposition leader to Putin, who's now been put in jail for three years. So, our subjects were our way of protesting the technology. But that's going to come out next year.

broomberg-chanarin-interview-3.jpg broomberg-chanarin-interview-4.jpg
Is this the "War Primer 2" debut in America?

It is. We only made 100 of them because they are so laborious. We literally hand-screen printed them. Each picture is stuck in by hand on top. And we sold them for $100 each, just because—it shouldn't be a rarefied object.

That's why you made it available for free, online?

Exactly.

broomberg-chanarin-interview-10.jpg
Some of the images you and Oliver chose in "War Primer 2" are very graphic. As we are increasingly exposed to violence and gore, and as it is depicted more frequently and accurately, do you think we become desensitized?

I don't think we are desensitized to violent images. What's more shocking is how sanitized the depiction of the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq was. I mean, it was very hard to find a violent image unless you look very hard on the internet. Certainly in the mainstream news.

Does this censorship come from the government?

There's a kind of relationship between—newspapers rely on advertisers to get their income. Advertisers wouldn't deal with a picture of a mauled corpse on the cover. And I'm not saying that's the sole reason, but compare the way these wars were depicted to the way Vietnam was depicted. It's 50 years later and we've gone backwards in time. In the time of Larry Burrows—those images changed the course of history. People say part of the reason why the Vietnam War ended was because of those images. Whereas now, photographers are so controlled in war zones.

broomberg-chanarin-interview-1.jpg
That's a good point—as soon as you said "the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq," I couldn't visualize anything specific.

All you can think of is Abu Ghraib, right? That's it. And that came from a proper soldier, not a professional photographer. That's what the "War Primer" is really about. Brecht was looking at the way war was imaged. For instance, there's a picture of a Liverpool bombing—that must have been a radical thing to see in the '40s, an aerial view while it was being bombed—and we've superimposed over that an image of 9/11. That now is still very difficult to compute.

I was speaking to a good friend who lives in New York. He said there's two moments in his life where his eyes and his brain could not function together. One was 9/11 and the other one was Hurricane Sandy. He was in the midst of it—it was too much to take in, if you know what I mean. I think there are things that we are unable to process as images.

broomberg-chanarin-interview-5.jpg
Aside from reading the newspaper daily and keeping up with global political issues, what inspires your ideas for each new project?

Looking back at all these projects, there's a line of thinking and politics. The strategies are very different. Everything looks different because because it's appropriate for what we're dealing with. What you just saw is very different from "Afterlife." We're not committed to one aesthetic strategy, but we're always interrogating photography. It's history and it's future.

broomberg-chanarin-interview-6.jpg broomberg-chanarin-interview-7.jpg
Since you and Oliver have done both in the past, do you feel more comfortable behind the camera or working with photos that have already been taken?

We just got to a point where it felt a little bit uncomfortable traveling around the world and taking pictures of people who had no idea about the political, economical, cultural power of that image once it's out there in the world. That became increasingly uncomfortable for us. So I think that's when we started looking at archives and material that was already out there. But we wouldn't call ourselves archive artists—it's much more of a collaborative process with the subjects rather than documentary, like a camera in a psychiatric hospital.

What are the benefits to working as a long-term duo? It's rare in photography, but even in the bigger art world.

Traditionally when we do take pics, we use a camera that has a plate so you can both look and both frame. Now we hardly remember who took the actual picture. There's something about being two people—photography people find it very uncomfortable because there's this myth of the "photographer's eye" and their sense of timing, and the duo undoes that, right? There's also a sense of anonymity: I don't own the work, Ollie doesn't own the work, we kind of share that. I find it very liberating. When we get emails, we bounce the questions between us. After 15 years of working with somebody, you fill in the gaps. You know what's going on in each other's minds. Photography's horribly lonely.

broomberg-chanarin-interview-8.jpg

View Broomberg and Chanarin's "War Primer 2" at the New Photography 2013 exhibition, which runs until 6 January 2014 at MoMA in New York. While only 100 copies of "War Primer 2" were produced, the digital edition is free and available to the public online, accompanied by critical essays. Also catch the duo's other work, "Afterlife," on view at the Death of a Cameraman exhibition at Apexart, which ends 26 October.

Portrait courtesy of the artists. Single page images © Adam Broomberg, Oliver Chanarin, 2013, courtesy MACK. Photographed book spreads © Adam Broomberg, Oliver Chanarin, 2013, courtesy MAPP

The CH25 is a showcase of creators and innovators from a broad range of disciplines who are currently working to drive the world forward.

Cynthia Breazeal

How an emotional, empathetic robot named Jibo stands to revolutionize communication

Read More
The thing that's so provocative about social robots is that it's fundamentally a community technology

Eelke Plasmeijer

The locally driven restaurant that’s upending Balinese food culture

Read More
We really try to keep things simple and let the produce do the talking

Matt Kenyon

Fusing art and technology to disrupt concepts of corporate America

Read More
I want the work to live in the world and circulate, so it can generate more dialogue

Roxie Darling

From un-shampoo to transgender identity, the NYC colorist boldly defining the next chapter of hair

Read More
Hair color is as much a science as it is a craft

Tarren Wolfe

The next-generation appliance making kitchens greener—literally

Read More
Our goal is to provide food for everyone in the world, and the best place to start is in our very own community

Sarah Kunst

The entrepreneur single-handedly changing the landscape for women in tech

Read More
People who live on a planet that is half women but can never seem to find any when they need one, I have solved your problem

Corinne Joachim Sanon

The chocolatier bringing social change to Haiti and bean-to-bar chocolate to the world

Read More
Seeing the poverty surrounding me and the lack of jobs and opportunity bothered me

Dan Barasch + James Ramsey

A quest to make the future brighter—underground

Read More
We both share a passion for groundbreaking technology and a shared love of New York

George Arriola and Monohm

An heirloom electronic for the post-smartphone era

Read More
We agonized during the design process as all hyper-obsessed craftspeople should

Marcus Weller

Using technology to turn motorcycle helmet design on its head

Read More
I was taken aback both by the number of people that doubted it, and by the equally large number of people that got behind it

Vanessa Newman

Redesigning pregnancy for the post-gender generation with Butchbaby & Co.

Read More
I want my customers to feel comfortable and unchanged, in that becoming pregnant didn't take away from or compromise their identity

Tal Danino

The bioengineer who’s programming DNA to fight cancer

Read More
[Manipulating genes] is very new, people are just learning how to program these organisms

Alex Kalman

The tiny museum in Manhattan that’s redefining museums

Read More
The mission is to put this small simple and powerful tool into the hands of as many people as possible

Douglas Riboud + Justin Guilbert

How a mission to create great coconut water led to a whole new way of doing business

Read More
We’ve made a conscious decision to be as transparent and honest as we can, and let people decide for themselves

Joshua Harker

Pushing the boundaries of sculpture with intricate 3D printing

Read More
My intent was to explore and depict the architecture of the imagination, to interpret and share forms evident in the mind’s eye

Melissa Kushner

Addressing the needs of orphans and vulnerable children in Malawi through microenterprise

Read More
Poverty is complicated, there is an increasing temptation and pressure in the development space to oversimplify things

Lulu Mickelson

A civic leader bringing change to NYC through design

Read More
Human-centered design is one of the many tools that we can use to better engage the public

Leopoldine Huyghues Despointes

The young filmmaker and non-profit founder who just wants people to follow their dreams

Read More
I feel confident and ready to accomplish so much more, the movement is on

Jonathan Sparks

Reinventing electronic music by inventing multi-disciplinary instruments

Read More
Recorded music is becoming so cheap, so the value of music is now in live performance

Kegan Schouwenburg

Revolutionizing orthotics through 3D-printed insoles

Read More
What orthotics do is they effectively change the geometry of what your alignment is like

LaToya Ruby Frazier

Documenting the slow, troubling change in Braddock, Pennsylvania

Read More
I am not a journalist, I am a conceptual documentary artist using my visual expression for building narratives that are unseen and unheard

Pauline van Dongen

The Dutch designer blazing the wearable technology path

Read More
I’m fascinated by concepts of change, movement, energy and perception; since they are closely related to the way we experience the world

Sabine Seymour

A future where smart clothes are as ubiquitous as zippers

Read More
In the future you will not buy a piece of 'functional' clothing without SoftSpot

Kathleen Supové

The NYC performance artist who’s radically reinventing the piano recital

Read More
I like pieces that are virtuosic, that show off the piano and what it can do, and are awe-inspiring

Meredith Perry

How searching the Internet helped a 22-year-old invent wireless electricity

Read More
It’s not about where the information is, it’s about how you use the tools
Loading More...